Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Playing god

I've always kind of wondered about the phrase "playing god", particularly when it come to science the medical field. Like always there are people who see black and white and people who see gray. So what and who defines playing god? There are ways for geneticists to determine what genetic abnormalities you and your offspring will have. And although I'm sure it will be frowned upon, geneticists will soon (if they can't already) extract the genes that contain alzheimers, autism, cancer, muscular distrophy, and other genetic orders. I can see an argument for people saying that that's playing god. But I get confused when I think about the same people AGAINST that being FOR research for cures of all the above. So what's the difference between dragging your child through years of therapy, operations, pain, and medication to reach an eradication of the disease, and eliminating the disease before the person is born?

Indifferent reason tells me that the genetic "engineering" is the way to go, but the other half of me says that while it makes sense, it's just not natural. There's something disturbing to me about eliminating the aspect of the natural genetic "roll of the dice". But how humane is this dice roll when it can lead to down syndrome, autism, etc. And what about human vegetables on life support? Is it playing god by keeping the person alive with man made machines, or would it be playing god by standing aside and doing nothing when having the ability to keep them alive? I guess it's pretty hard to technically define which is which. But I can say it'd be pretty kooky for anyone to be on the extreme ends of the spectrum. In other words, while it's creepy to want to custom create a genetic spawn of perfection, it's equally disturbing for me to hear about people who refuse to treat a child with a genetic disease because "that's how god" made them.

No comments:

Post a Comment